If you are someone who loves shopping for clothes, what better way to feed your shopping addiction than actually selling clothes yourself? Matilda Jane MLM could possibly make that happen for you. In this Matilda Jane MLM review, I’ll look inside to see if this is a bargain or a big disappointment.
In order to make the Matilda Jane MLM work for you, it would also help to know a lot of women and/or people with kids since that is the target market here. The prices of the products aren’t too bad but may be out of reach for families that do not have a lot of disposable income.
What is Matilda Jane MLM?
Matilda Jane is a multi-level marketing (MLM) company that is based in Fort Wayne, Indiana. The company was founded in 2006 by Denise DeMarchis. The clothing is targeted specifically to women and girls of all ages and includes accessories as well as products for the home. Have a look at this video overview of the ‘Spirit of Matilda Jane’ before reading on.
How Does Matilda Jane Work?
The clothes are sold through Trunk Keepers who are essentially distributors. Like most MLMs, you would make sales by having someone host a party. In return for the party, the host would qualify for a gift. Any sales from the party are sent directly to the company to be fulfilled and will be shipped directly to the customer.
Can You Make Money With Matilda Jane?
It may be difficult to make a lot of money with Matilda Jane. As a Trunk Keeper you are not really selling anything exclusive. These clothes can also be purchased online directly from the website as well as through other sites such as Zulily, Amazon or eBay.
So in order for you to make any DECENT money, you would need to recruit a downline of people who would sell clothing under your sponsorship. You would earn a percentage of their sales.
What Is A Jane?
A Jane is someone who is a hostess of a Matilda show. As a Jane hosting a show, you would earn either a discount or free products depending on the amount of sales from the show. Unfortunately, the discounts aren’t great. In order to get 50% off one item, your show needs to produce at least $300 in sales.
As you can see from the image above, 50% off one item is the bare minimum gift your host will receive. But 50% off one item doesn’t sound like a lot of incentive for a host to throw a party. Maybe it’s just me. Unless, of course, your host invites tons of people which is also possible, I guess. But having a lot of people at a party doesn’t necessarily translate into sales.
Available in the U.S. and Canada
Not restricted to where or who you can sell to within the United States and Canada.
As a Trunk Keeper, you will receive training and a personalized development plan free of charge.
Good Commission Rates
Trunk Keepers earn a commission rate of 20% for any products they sell. Unfortunately, that’s the only commission rate I could find.
Plenty of Variety
There is an extensive catalog of clothes ranging from clothes for children, women and baby clothes. There are also accessories such as small bags and toys and even products for the home such as pillows, blankets and bedding.
High Startup Costs
Not only do you have to buy a starter kit here, you are also obligated to buy a seasonal kit every time a new line of clothes comes out. And you have to buy it at retail prices–not wholesale prices. The startup kit alone will set you back $1,600.
As a Trunk Keeper, you have to pay a non-refundable deposit of $300 by credit card in order to become a Trunk Keeper.
Buy A Trunk
As a Trunk Keeper, you will also be required to purchase a trunk at the beginning of every Selling Season at the stated price.
You are not permitted to promote clothes through ads on Facebook. You also cannot promote through ads you create yourself.
You Pay To Terminate
If you wake up one morning and decide that you no longer wish to be a Trunk Keeper, you have to notify Matilda Jane in writing and send that notification via Federal Express at your own expense.
The Charges Don’t Stop There
Matilda Jane can still bill you for commission refunds from customer returns or exchanges after your termination.
Maintain Monthly Sales Target
In order to stay in the game as a Trunk Keeper, you will need to maintain at least $1,500 of sales per month.
Beware of Lawsuits
This information should really be in the Con Section but I thought it should be highlighted. There’s a woman in West Virginia who is actually suing Matilda Jane for poor labor practices. She was under the impression that she should be making at least minimum wage which is certainly not the case.
My guess is that the woman didn’t really know what she was getting into when she signed up for Matilda Jane MLM. She probably didn’t understand that you only make money on commission. And you are only paid a commission if you reach your sales quotas. But I thought it was definitely worth mentioning here.
Is Matilda Jane Legitimate?
The problem with MLMs is that they seem legitimate because it’s basically you are working as an affiliate or distributor to sell someone else’s product in exchange for commissions. But let’s think about that for a moment. You only make money from sales. There’s no hourly rate here. That means that you could work like a dog chasing people to buy merchandise and spending tons of time and money out of your own pocket knowing that the end result could be a big fat 0. No sales.
The other problem with MLMs is that there’s a lot of cost to you upfront. You have to buy your kit and all your startup materials in advance before you even arrange to have someone host a party.
Then there’s the recruitment issue. If you want to make more money, you’ll need to recruit a downline of people that work under your sponsorship. You will then earn money from any sales they make.
MLMs are great at making their products seem glamorous and easy to sell with catch phrases such as “these products are so good, they sell themselves.” I’m sure you’ve heard that before, right?
What they don’t tell you is how much work you will have to put into your business in order to make even small commissions. For anyone who needs a full-time income, this is a long game where you probably can’t wait for the payoff. Not to mention the high upfront costs.
With Matilda Jane products you are not giving your potential customers anything exclusive because those customers can also buy online directly from the Matilda Jane site or even other sites such as Zulily, Amazon or eBay.
If you are really interested in creating your own home business, check out my #1 recommendation on how to build a successful business. You’ll get plenty of support, training, websites, and access to 24/7 live chat where people are always online to help you.
11 thoughts on “Matilda Jane MLM Review”
If someone was not aware what an MLM, then it’s easy to see how they would get sucked into Matilda Jane. Especially if they are into clothing and fashion. The site gives off a very vibrant joyful vibe, and it’s explained in their Story page that they like to have a family atmosphere amongst their Trunk Keepers. However, it seems that when a new beginner joins as Trunk Keeper, they are basically forced to buy the seasonal trunks. Almost like they are just being used to profit for others.
It’s a shame, because a company like this starting off had the right message and idea, but now it seems its all about the $$$.
Major issue currently for trunk keepers is being able to get MJ products for their customers before they sell out. The trunk keepers stay up all night To input their preorder sales just to be blocked from entering MJ system or are told product sold out. This is during preorder!!!! They continue to push trunk keepers to sign up new trunk keepers when they do NOT have product to support the customer orders for their current trunk keepers. BIG pyramid scheme going on at the expense and livelihood of their trunk keepers. The trunk keepers at top of pyramid seem to have no trouble getting their customer orders filled where a newer trunk keeper can’t even get access to system. They are also currently not providing the promised trunks for new releases to the trunk keepers. HUGE scam going on by this company. I just did some research and since the original owner Denise died of cancer in 2015 the board consists of men!!! Tell me what’s wrong with this picture????
Unless someone has had experience working a commission-only job, I don’t think they realize what they’re getting into. With this type of party-plan MLM, the challenges just get compounded. There’s an amazing amount of work involved between getting a hostess to agree to give a party and actually having people with spendable income show up and place orders. It looks like a quick trip to burn-out to me! Thanks for such a focused and informative review.
Former Trunk Keeper here. Most of this is correct. The commission isn’t great unless you recruit more people. Selling is hard because a lot of people don’t want to spend $34 on a baby romper, dress, etc.
I do want to point out that TK’s have the option of resigning via an online form. That’s how I did it.
My advice, don’t do it unless you know a ton of people and have a little-little girl that you can dress up in MJ for real-life photos & make her wear the clothes EVERYWHERE. Just MHO.
Thank you Mandy for your thoughts!
Agree with all of this. I am also a former trunk keeper, was for 4 years and loved the discounts for myself and my littles. The biggest problem I saw was the $2500 trunk each season (twice a year). If you had a big enough following you can sell your samples at the end of the season to pay for your next trunk but at only 20% commission, it’s hardly worth the time and effort to host shows, lug the rack and clothes around and then work on returns/exchanges and deal with unhappy customers because they have to pay shipping. Lol.
Such a high cost to enter…although I think that many of the clothing MLMs operate in this fashion (no pun intended).
Thanks for the review
Looks like you were in a generous mood when you rated 6.3 Jay :) With those cons, I wouldn’t even think of going for it. Thank you for the detailed review.
As with most MLM offers, the most important step is to diligently consider the terms and conditions and read as many reviews as possible before making a committed decision. The Matilda Jane MLM is one of such offers that one should be weary of, mainly because it puts you on a target lane and doesnt give the option of advertising on the best source of targeted traffic. Do you know why they dont allow subscribers to run ads? The lifeline of any business is convertion and the future is really bleak for any business that does not have a repeated way of constantly generating sales. Thanks for this amazing review that practically points out the loopholes in Matilda Jane MLM and also gives us good alternative. I will definitely come back for more resources in future. Cheers!
I was just watching a video of this while process on how this company works and I found it really intriguing to see how these women were planning out everything. From delivery’s to hosting the gatherings and from what I gathered, some of them were actually really successful doing so. It’s a lot of work, but maybe the payout is good.
As an affiliate marketer, I am always looking for things that I can link to as an affiliate. This was a thorough like at this particular MLM. It seems that if the clothing line is sold other than through house parties that maybe be an issue. Is is possible to be an affiliate without purchasing an inventory? A link on a website would seem to be a good way to add this clothing line to a website. Thanks for the article and for the honest review.